Logo
Back

What is the difference between angular-route and angular-ui-router?

AngularJS provides flexible ways to structure your application’s views and navigation. Two of the most popular options for managing routes are angular-route (the built-in AngularJS router) and angular-ui-router (a third-party library often referred to as UI-Router). In this blog, we’ll explore the key differences between them, so you can decide which is best for your AngularJS project. We’ll also touch on resources that can further strengthen your skills in front-end development and system design.

Quick Overview

  • angular-route

    • Official router from the AngularJS team
    • Basic approach using a singular view per route
    • Straightforward configuration for smaller or simpler apps

  • angular-ui-router

    • A more feature-rich, community-maintained library
    • Uses a state-based approach
    • Supports nested and named views for more complex UI requirements

1. Conceptual Approach: Routes vs. States

angular-route follows a route-based approach. You define each route alongside a template and controller. When a user navigates to a certain URL, AngularJS swaps out the template in ng-view based on your configuration. This approach is simple: one route → one view → one controller.

angular-ui-router takes a state-based approach. Instead of routes that map a URL to a template, you create states that can correspond to any unique part of your application. URLs still matter, but states bring extra flexibility:

  • Multiple URLs can point to the same state.
  • A single state can render multiple named views simultaneously.

2. Support for Nested and Multiple Views

With angular-route, each route can replace a single template in the ng-view. This limitation can make it challenging to build applications that have multiple, separately updating sections (e.g., a sidebar and a main content area).

By contrast, angular-ui-router supports nested and named views:

  • Nested Views allow you to define child states where each child has its own view hierarchy.
  • Named Views let you populate multiple view regions on the page simultaneously.

This structure is particularly useful for complex layouts—think dashboards or multi-region templates.

3. Configuration and Syntax

angular-route:

angular.module('myApp', ['ngRoute'])
  .config(function($routeProvider) {
    $routeProvider
      .when('/home', {
        templateUrl: 'home.html',
        controller: 'HomeController'
      })
      .otherwise({ redirectTo: '/home' });
  });

Configuration is fairly straightforward, with .when() and .otherwise() chaining.

angular-ui-router:

angular.module('myApp', ['ui.router'])
  .config(function($stateProvider, $urlRouterProvider) {
    $stateProvider
      .state('home', {
        url: '/home',
        templateUrl: 'home.html',
        controller: 'HomeController'
      });
    $urlRouterProvider.otherwise('/home');
  });

Here, you define states with $stateProvider. Each state can have its own configuration for URLs, templates, and controllers, and you can nest or name views as needed.

4. Transition Hooks and Advanced Features

angular-route offers lifecycle hooks such as resolve for preloading data. However, it’s limited in how you can intercept or manage route transitions.

angular-ui-router shines in this department: you have powerful transition hooks like $transitions.onStart, $transitions.onSuccess, and $transitions.onError, making it easier to handle authentication checks, lazy loading, or logging. This advanced flexibility can be a game-changer in large-scale applications.

5. Which One Should You Use?

  • Choose angular-route if:

    • Your application is small or straightforward.
    • You only need a single main view that changes based on the route.
    • You prefer a simpler, more minimal setup out of the box.

  • Choose angular-ui-router if:

    • Your application is medium to large in scope.
    • You need nested, named, or multiple parallel views.
    • You want more flexibility and advanced transition management.

Tips for Building Better AngularJS Apps

  1. Leverage Components
    While routes and states are essential, moving repeated functionalities into components (or directives) can reduce complexity.

  2. Optimize Performance
    Keep an eye on watchers and digest cycles. If you notice your app slowing down, consider using one-time bindings ({{ ::value }}) or reorganizing your scope structure.

  3. Refine Your Architecture
    A good application structure is key to maintainability. Even in AngularJS, adopting design patterns can help you write cleaner code.

Leveling Up Your Skills Beyond AngularJS

A solid routing strategy is just one part of building a scalable, maintainable front-end. If you’re aiming for top roles in software engineering, you’ll need broader proficiency in system design and coding patterns. Below are a few resources from DesignGurus.io that can help:

Additionally, the DesignGurus.io YouTube Channel offers free tutorials on system design and interview preparation. For hands-on experience with personalized feedback, consider their Coding Mock Interview or System Design Mock Interview.

Final Thoughts

Both angular-route and angular-ui-router solve the core problem of mapping URLs to templates, but they cater to different use cases. The official router (angular-route) is simpler and works great for smaller apps, whereas angular-ui-router (UI-Router) offers more complex state-based routing suitable for sophisticated layouts and multiple nested views.

Whichever you choose, remember that mastering AngularJS routing is just one piece of the puzzle. Continuously broadening your engineering skills—especially in system design, coding patterns, and scalable architecture—will keep you ahead in an ever-evolving tech landscape. Good luck, and happy coding!

CONTRIBUTOR
TechGrind